10 Key Differences Between Standing Seam and Corrugated Metal Roof

Standing Seam or Corrugated Metal Roof? Let’s discover 10 Key Differences. Metal roofs have taken the home and business world by storm. They are strong, durable, long lasting, and versatile. The two most common metal roofing styles are raised seam and ribbed panels metal roofs. By understanding the pros and cons of each type of roof, you can make an informed decision for your next roofing purchase.
So, let’s dismantle the whole topic into pieces: today we’re going to compare standing seam and corrugated metal roofs with respect to design, installation, durability, cost, application, performance, customization, maintenance, energy efficiency and environmental impact. By the end of the article, you’ll understand which one might be the right choice for your project.
Design and Appearance
Raised Seam Design
Vertical panels with raised seams that run continuously from the roof’s ridge down to the eaves create seamless metal roofs. The seams of these roofs might be 12 to 24 inches apart, depending on the manufacturer and the market. Their concealed fasteners allow standing seam roofs to have an ultra-modern, uninterrupted look, which is great for many contemporary architectural styles.
This type of design not only looks elegant but also great for weathertightness. Because the seams are raised above the flat surface of the roof, the interlocking seam roof can hold off water away from the roof, which is great for places that have a lot of rain or snow. Besides the advantages above, the standing seam roof is also very nice on the appearance, standing seam roofs can easily contribute to the curb appeal of your home, and boost its value on the market.
These roofs come in a variety of colours and finishes, so they can be done to match the style of your house or building. If you want a timeless look or a strikingly modern statement, seamless metal roofs deliver.
Corrugated Metal Design
Wavy and ribbed are ways to characterise the exterior design of the metal roof. The corrugation is an intentional design that makes the roof look traditional and unique. The design has been around for decades and is widely used for industrial and agricultural buildings. The waves in the sheet metal help distribute the weight of the roof, making it stronger and able to withstand extreme weather conditions.
Corrugated metal panels with its industrial look is also appreciated in its own right, both in a rustic as well as a modern style. The wavy texture that comes from the metal panels brings an interesting surface irregularity to the building’s exterior elevation. It’s a simpler design than standing seam, but it has its own appeal and functionality.
Because metal panels are typically available in fewer colourways and finishes than seamless roofs, paint can be a good way to penetrate the plating and produce a matched aesthetic.
Installation Process
Installation of Standing Seam
Crucial is the interlocking metal roof, in which vertical panels are interlocked and then attached horizontally to the roof deck with concealed fasteners. This type of roofing is usually hand-installed by the roofing contractor.
The professional installation ensures that the pattern on the tiles is matched up at the seams and the roof is fully weatherproofed to make sure that there are no water leaks or other problems. The installation may be more difficult and time-consuming, but the end product is a very good, long-lasting roof.
Because of their special installation, these premium roofs are often somewhat higher priced, but a seamless roof will last longer, work better and look better, and is therefore well worth the additional cost.
To ensure the best installation results, hire a professional metal roofing contractor to install the raised seam roof who is experienced enough to do it right.
Installation of Ribbed Panels
Corrugated roofs are less laborious to install than hidden fastener roofs; instead of locking the panels together, the panels are overlapped, then fastened in place with exposed screws or nails. The overlapping design is less precise and less time-consuming to install than a standing seam roof, which makes it a nice option for DIY homeowners.
One of the main advantages of these panels is the speed of installation, and often they can be installed without professional help, although, in our opinion, professional installation is always better. In this case, not only the fastenings of the panels can be done professionally, but the work of the roof as a whole is made weatherproof.
Read more: Metal Roofing in Coastal Areas
Durability and Lifespan
Durability of Standing Seam
The concealed fasteners help prevent water penetration into the roofing, and the secure attachment of the raised seam roof to the roof deck reduces the possibility of wind uplift (the force that could lift off a roof), which is especially important for areas with violent weather. Raised seam roofs are praised by roofing professionals for their high level of durability.
Typically made of high-quality steel or aluminium that won’t rust or corrode, standing seam roofs will last for many years and can easily stretch to 50 years or more with regular upkeep. The cost of maintaining a these premium roofing option will be lower in the long term when compared with other types of roofs because there is little chance that it will need a repair.
Not only do them withstand the harsh effects of weather, but they are also fire-resistant, able to hold their own in high-wind events.
Durability of Corrugated Roofs
The roofs are also durable because the wavy roof pattern adds rigidity to the metal, making it able to withstand heavier loads and impacts than smooth roofs. For this reason, ribbed metal roofing is used in areas that may be exposed to hail, snow and other harsh conditions.
However, the exposed fasteners may be a point of weakness. Over time, fasteners may become loose or corrode, causing leaks and the need for maintenance. Inspections and timely repairs are necessary to keep the roof functioning.
Anyway, despite these potential problems, a well-maintained corrugated metal roof can last a long time. With proper care and attention to details, it can last between 30 to 40 years or more. The best way to achieve a longer lifespan of this metal roof type is to take care of it, by solving any problems when they arise, and also to maintain it well.
Cost and Budget Considerations
Cost of Seamless Roofing
Standing seam metal roofs are generally more expensive than corrugated metal roofs. The initial investment is compensated by the durability, service life and low maintenance (a seamless roof needs little maintenance over the years) requirements of the roof. The higher initial investment of a raised seam roof can be paid off throughout the service life by the reduced repairs costs as well as the improved and modern looking design of the building.
Just request estimates from good roofing contractors or use our online roofing calculator, and spread out the cost over your roof’s service life. The end result can and should be look and worry-free.
Cost of Ribbed Panels
Corrugated metal roofs are more economical due to their lower-cost materials and installation costs when compared to standing seam roofs. Interlocking metal roof components are more complex – they have a tent-like appearance, involve additional parts, and are more challenging to install, which drives up the cost. By contrast, ribbed panels can often be installed over existing roofs, and the installation process itself is less complex, lowering labor costs.
The initial cost of a corrugated roofing is less expensive than tile, but keep in mind the extra ongoing maintenance expenses. You’ll have to tighten the exposed fasteners to the roof periodically or perhaps even replace them. And you’ll need to repair your roof occasionally for leaks or some other roof problem.
Overall, although corrugated roofs can have slightly higher maintenance costs, they are still one of the best options for those looking for affordability and durability from agricultural roofing.
Application and Usage
Applications for Standing Seam
Snap Lock metal roofs are most suitable for modern buildings. They are frequently used in high-end projects. Such roofs can add modern appearance to any property. Standing Seam roofs are widely used in commercial and institutional buildings because of easy installability, durability, and resistance to weather events of all kinds.
In conclusion, these roofs have many applications in residential buildings and are commonly used in buildings such as offices, schools, hospitals, etc, even in remote areas exposed to extreme weather conditions.
Applications for Corrugated Metal
Different shapes are used in agriculture, industry, and rustic contexts. The traditional and industrial aesthetic lends itself well to being used for barns, sheds, and other structures related to agriculture. Its strength and durability makes corrugated metal a great material to build structures that need to withstand heavy loads and impacts.
This type of metal roofs is also used as the roofing of buildings of a rustic or industrial aesthetic in residential and commercial settings.
AG (ribbed) metal roofing are suitable for all purposes because it is worthy and provides the best value for money when compared to other roofing materials. The appearance can also be rendered using paint or applying the suitable coatings.
Performance and Weather Resistance
Weather Resistance of Raised Seam
Since they have concealed fasteners and vertical panels, these roofs have excellent rain and snow shedding capacities. Raised seams also protect the structure from wind, keeping it dry and minimizing the risk of leaks and water damage on the inside.
The metal materials on standing seam roofs, such as steel and aluminium, are resistant to rust and corrosion, so that the roof will not just maintain its performance but also its appearance through the worst of weather.
This kind of roofing is not only water-resistant, but fire-resistant too, offering a secondary defense to the building. Along with the aforementioned positive attributes – weather protection, durability, and a longer lifespan – the ease of maintenance makes this type of raised seam metal roof a great choice for long-term performance.
Weather Resistance of Corrugated Metal
Especially under the corrugated roof design, it has a good resistance against wind and water. Even though the inside is flat, the corrugations can increase the strength. The wavy pattern can help to throw off water and snow, and keep water infiltration to a minimum. But the exposed fasteners can be the weak spots where water can leak through in the course of time.
To keep a corrugated roof weather resistant, regular inspection and maintenance must be carried out. To do this, many roofing experts recommend that all fasteners which hold the roof in place be inspected, and that any potential leak points be dealt with soon after.
In climates that are moderate to mild, ribbed metal roofing is a good choice. In some extreme climates, however, it will require more maintenance. With regular maintenance, however, a metal panels roof will stand up to the elements and give years of service.
Read more: Metal Roofing in Summer 2024 vs. Asphalt Shingles
Customization and Aesthetic Options
Customization of Interlocking Seam Roofs
Metal hidden fasteners roofs are highly customisable, with a range of colours and finishes available. Homeowners can pick standard colours or have these roofs painted to order to achieve a particular look. The polished, modern look of seamless roofs can go well with contemporary buildings.
Along with the colours, panel widths and seam heights can also be customised, further adding to the ability to create a custom look on a building. This makes standing seam metal roofs an attractive and popular option for high-end architectural projects.
Customization of Corrugated Metal
While corrugated metal roofs are less likely to be available in lots of colours and finishes the way that raised seam roofs are, they can be painted to suit any desired aesthetic. The industrial feel of working-class agricultural areas is preserved.
Though they have fewer options for customising their buildings, the corrugation template is still handy for adding visual interest to the exterior of the building because of the template’s unique texture. Flat sheet metal is more easily dented or marred and doesn’t look as interesting. The wavy pattern also works well with rustic or industrial architectural styles, so it’s not surprising that ribbed metal buildings are popular with aesthetics in mind.
Corrugated metal could be the most versatile, practical and aesthetically straightforward roofing material there is. It’s possible to buy roofing solutions that look like ribbed metal but are actually just creative designs.
Read more: Painting Metal Roof: 7 Reasons why it is the Best Investment for Your Home
Maintenance Requirements
Maintenance for Seamless Roof
Metal roofing with a vertical seams system provides a low maintenance roof. Because this roof has durable materials and hidden fasteners, it comes up with less chances of leaks and other problems compared to other roofing systems. Due to this feature, maintenance cost becomes very low in the long term. This metal roofing system requires periodic inspection to ensure that the roof is performing well.
Routine maintenance to standing seam roofs includes cleaning the surface of the roof (to remove debris) and checking for any breakage in panels and signs of wear to ensure the performance of the roof.
Interlocking seam metal roofs boast a low maintenance and durable nature, allowing them to last for years with little to no upkeep. Home owners thus have access to a quality roof with minimal hassles.
To sum up, the maintenance work for snap lock roofs is not very frequent, less than the other types of roofs.
Maintenance for Ribbed Panels Metal Roof
The exposed fasteners that are found on most corrugated metal roofs mean that the roof will require more frequent maintenance than other types. Periodic inspections (recommended every six months) can help you keep the fasteners in good condition by inspecting for loose or corroded fasteners and making minor repairs to keep any leaks at bay.
Besides maintenance of fasteners, the roof panels should be frequently cleaned to remove deposits of dirt and debris that might cause rust or corrosion. Protective coatings are also available to extend the lifespan of the system.
Despite the need for more maintenance , the longevity and affordability of rural metal roofs makes them the obvious choice in many contexts. Homeowners and farmers who stay on top of maintenance will find that simple upkeep can help their metal roof look great, last longer, and perform better.
Energy Efficiency
Energy Efficiency of Standing Seam
Snap lock metal roofs are the most energy-efficient, due in part to reflective coatings on the panels that help to deflect heat absorption, keeping the building cooler in the summer months, decreasing cooling costs and creating more energy savings in the future.
Another benefit of seamless roof design is the ability to install solar panels for the generation of renewable energy, resulting in a decorative roofing system that also promotes energy efficiency. The reflective coating and potential for solar energy generation make standing seam roofs a ‘green’ material.
Moreover, such energy conservation also leads to a more comfortable living or working environment and a cooler space. If a building has requirements to minimize the heat gain, vertical seam roofs are good at improving energy efficiency, thus providing a good return on investment.
Energy Efficiency of Corrugated Metal
These metal roofs are moderately energy efficient. Since they do not have as reflective a coating as a snap lock roof, energy efficiency of a corrugated metal roof will be lower. However, if you need lower heating cost you could apply reflective coating on a ribbed metal roof.
Moreover, corrugated roofs allow for good ventilation, which can help to maintain an indoor temperature. This way, natural ventilation can contribute to the comfort of the indoors and could reduce the use of artificial cooling.
To summarise, corrugated panels have practical advantages as well. It is not as energy-efficient as raised seam. However, it can save lots of energy and can make the building more sustainable.
Environmental Impact
Environmental Impact of Standing Seam
The materials used in these metal roofs are usually recyclable, which makes it an environmentally-friendly roofing option. Because of the long service life of this roofing system, the frequency of replacing your roof will be reduced which means more waste reduction over time. What’s more, the energy efficiency of seamless roofs will lead to less energy consumption and a smaller carbon footprint.
Because solar panels can be attached to raised seam roofs, this option contributes to an even greener lifestyle. By using solar panels, homeowners can have their roofs generate clean renewable energy and reduce reliance on fossil fuels. The longevity, energy efficiency and recyclability of SSMR contribute to a more sustainable future.
A standing seam metal roof offers a greener roofing solution to those who are seeking an eco-friendly approach to their roofing needs. The long-term benefits and the positive environmental impact of a interlocking seam roof makes this roofing choice a sound and eco-friendly investment for those who care about the environment.
Environmental Impact of Corrugated Metal
Moreover, corrugated metal’s roofs are eco-friendly as many of them are produced from recycled material. The recycling of corrugated metal panels at the end of their life further decreases their environmental footprint. For a homeowner, there are no better options than corrugated metal.
Even though the lifespan of a corrugated metal roof is shorter than a standing seam roof, maintenance and prompt repair can prolong their useful life, thereby reducing frequent replacements and minimising waste. And a ribbed metal roof’s energy efficiency reduces energy consumption, with the added benefit of lowering the carbon footprint.
In conclusion, I would say that corrugated metal roofs are a practical and ecological covering. As it is durable, recyclable and saves energy, and the responsible material for green-minded people, making their houses more proficient.
Conclusion
In conclusion, both standing seam roof and corrugated metal roof have their particular features and are suitable for different kinds of applications respectively. The raised seam roof provides a clean, modern look with great weathering and durability, which is good to use for the high-end residential and commercial projects. The corrugated metal roof has an industrial, traditional look with lower cost, it is a great option for the agricultural, industrial and rustic kinds of applications.
However, by identifying the critical differences between these two types of metal roof products, homeowners and businesses can select the roof that best suits their needs. Whether your goal is aesthetics, longevity, price or green initiatives, snap lock and ribbed metal roofing each provide long-lasting roofing solutions.
If you are thinking about having a metal roof and are considering Professional Metal Roofing for your roofing project, give us a call 647 250 1727 for a consultation or request an estimate on our website. We can help you pick the best roofing system that meets your needs. To read more about metal roofing and other roofing related subjects, please read our other blogs.
Read more: How to Choose the Perfect Metal Panel Roof for Your Home: A Guide to Different Types
See our works
Giving you a sense of what a metal roof will look like in your home of commercial property