Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost Comparison

Metal roof vs shingles cost: which roofing option is worth the investment?  Total price is the primary consideration when comparing a metal roof vs shingles cost. The two types of roofs are distinct from each other in terms of price and long-term costs that can both impact the budget now and into the future. Although shingles are generally more affordable in the beginning ($2.50 to $5 per square foot), they will often be more expensive in the long run due to their low maintenance and decreased lifespan. Metal roofs, which range from $4.49 per square foot (up to $18 for more expensive styles), have higher initial costs but come with substantial savings in durability, maintenance, and energy efficiency. 

We’ll dive deep into the total metal roof vs shingles cost, from installation costs to long-term maintenance, replacement, and overall long-term value. If you’re a homeowner who wants to save as much as possible in the short and long term, knowing what the differences in cost are will help you decide which roof investment makes the most sense for you. 

Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost for Initial Installation  

Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost of Materials  

Metal roofs begin at $4.49 per square foot, and some styles range to $7 per square foot, with high-end standing seam systems priced starting at $9 per square foot and upwards of $18. Shingle roofs, however, generally cost between $2.50 and $5 per square foot, depending on the quality. The material price of metal reflects its durability and longevity.

Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost of Labour

Metal roof vs shingles cost of labour also varies, steel roofs are difficult to erect and require professional skills for intricate designs such as standing seam. Professional installation ensures proper sealing and longevity, which incurs extra labor costs. Shingle roofs, which are easier to put on, save labor but may need replacing more often (typically each 15-20 years).

Installation Timeline

Metal roofs take more time to set up, especially in complex designs, resulting in increased work hours. Shingles can be put up more quickly, usually within a day or two in standard homes. But the extra time on metal roofs ensures a more durable build.

Upcoming expenses

• Metal roof: $4.49–$18 per sq.ft. based on design
• Shingles: $2.50–$5 per sq.ft. depending on quality
• Metal roof labour charges are often higher
• Installation time is longer for metal than for shingles

Read more: Average Price to Replace an Asphalt Shingles Roof in Ontario

Long-Term Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost

• Durability and Lifespan

Metal roofs have an average life of 50+ years, which is far better than shingle, which has an average lifespan of 15–25 years. This long life means less replacement costs down the line, and that makes metal an attractive option for long-term homeowners.

• Maintenance Costs

Keeping your metal roof clean doesn’t take much time, which can save you a lot of money over the years. Generally, the more exposed shingles will require more repairs and replacements, particularly in hot weather.

• Repair and Replacement

Shingles might need to be replaced if they are damaged by wind or rain. Roofs made of metal are much less vulnerable to a break, though isolated dents or corrosion may require maintenance. This makes metal roof vs shingles cost cheaper in the long run.

Long-Term Cost Factors

• Durability: Metal (50+ years) vs. Shingles (15–25 years)
• Maintenance: Low for metal, moderate for shingles
• Repairs: Generally higher for shingles, less high for metal.
• Replacement: Metal seldom replaced, shingles more frequently replaced.

When looking at Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost, it’s clear that while shingles may be appealing for short-term savings, metal roofs provide greater financial stability over time.

Energy Efficiency and Utility Savings

• Energy Efficiency of Metal Roofing

Metal roofs reflect the sun, and will minimize the loss of heat and cooling costs in the hottest regions. This reflective property saves you a monthly air conditioning bill, especially in the summer.

• Shingle Energy Consumption

Shingle roofs are insulators and can lead to higher cooling bills in warmer climates. Darker shingles in particular tend to warm up the indoor environment, and metal is much more energy efficient.

• Long-Term Savings Potential

Metal roofing can outperform a high upfront price in the long run because of its energy efficiency. Metal roofing can significantly reduce energy costs, depending on local climate and sun exposure.

Energy Factors

• Metal Roof vs shingles cost is lower due to reduced cooling/heating costs
• Shingles raise cooling demands in hotter regions
• Long-term metal roof vs shingles cost savings from metal’s reflectivity
• Region-specific energy impact

Read more: Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles in Ontario: An In-Depth Analysis

Real Homeowner’s Insight

Clarissa Richardson, who replaced her 2022 home with a metal roof, says she’s experienced a huge reduction in utility costs since upgrading. “Our energy bills dropped significantly, particularly during the summer,” Clarissa said. “Before, the AC was always on so that the house cooled down. We’ve saved money on cooling costs ever since the metal roof was installed because it keeps the house cooler by itself. Her experience echoes the long-term savings of metal roofing.

“I decided to go with a metal roof in 2022 after a summer of very high utility bills. I’d heard that metal roofs could help keep homes cooler, and I wanted to see if it could make a real difference for us. Our house is around 2,200 square feet, and we live in a warm area where summers can be intense. Before the installation, our energy bills were averaging around $220 per month in the peak summer months. I wanted to find a way to lower that without compromising comfort.

After we had the metal roof installed, our energy costs started dropping right away. The summer months following the installation, our monthly utility bill went down to around $160 on average. That’s a $60 difference each month, and over the summer season, it added up to nearly $240 in savings. It was a significant drop, and it helped offset the initial cost of the roof faster than I expected.

The difference in indoor temperature was one of the first things we noticed. Previously, we had to keep the AC running nearly all day to keep things cool, especially in the afternoons. With the metal roof, the house stays cooler naturally. The AC isn’t kicking on as often, and we don’t feel that rush of heat when we walk in from outside. The whole house feels better insulated from the sun’s heat, which makes it easier to maintain a comfortable temperature.

For anyone struggling with high energy bills, especially in warmer climates, a metal roof is worth considering. It’s an investment, but the monthly savings add up. Over time, I can see how this will pay off, not only financially but in terms of a more comfortable home. Plus, it feels good knowing we’re using less energy. I’m glad I made the switch”.

Read more: 7 Powerful Reasons Why To Choose a Tin Roof

Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost based on Clarissa’s Savings:

• Home size: 2,200 sq.ft.
• Pre-installation utility cost (summer): $220/month
• Post-installation utility cost (summer): $160/month
• Monthly savings: $60
• Total savings over the year: Approximately $1100

Selling Value and Return on Investment 

• Impact on Property Value  

Metal roofs are usually considered a luxury addition, and may even add value to a home over shingles. Metal roofing can provide added strength for buyers, especially in upscale communities. 

• Return on Investment (ROI)  

Because metal has a better longevity and is much more durable, you typically earn a higher return on your investment because it improves the value of the asset over time. Even the cheapest shingles might not yield a greater ROI because of their shorter lifespan. 

• Regional Appeal  

The metal roofing is highly prized for weather resistance, so in some places buyers will prefer the metal roofing. In colder climates, metal is more durable too, making it worth purchasing. The Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost comparison becomes even more relevant in regions with harsh weather, where metal roofs require less frequent repairs.

Homeowners comparing Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost often find that while shingles are cheaper initially, metal roofs offer a lower total cost of ownership over time.

Value Factors

• Impact on property values: Higher for metals. 
• Return on investment: Higher for metal due to durability. 
• Regional appeal for durability  
• Buyer preference for long-lasting materials  

Read more:  Metal Roofing in Summer 2024 vs. Asphalt Shingles

Financing Options and Affordability  

• Payment Options for Metal and Shingle Roofing 

Metal roofs as well as shingle roofs offer financing options that may be available with manufacturers and contractors. Loans, credit cards, and monthly payments make the cost of upfront expenses manageable, particularly for metal roofs. 

• Monthly Payment Comparison  

Payments of metal roofs are higher each month (from $121/month) because they’re more expensive at first, but with less ongoing maintenance costs, the monthly cost can outweigh it. Shingles require a smaller monthly payment at the beginning but their shorter lifespan can incur costs down the line. 

• Special Financing for Metal Roofing  

Professional Metal Roofing offers wholesale pricing because we buy our materials in bulk and pass savings on to the customer. This means that our metal roofing is less expensive than its competitors. You can request your free estimate right here!

Financing Details  

• Manufacturer-backed financing options  
• Monthly payment options for each  
• Discounts for bulk purchases from Metal Exterior Products
• Special financing plans for metal  

The Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost comparison reveals that, although metal roofs are pricier upfront, their durability and energy efficiency can make them a more economical choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Metal Roof vs Shingles: What Is the Main Difference?

The primary difference between metal roofs and shingles is their material and durability. Metal roofs are typically made from aluminum or steel and offer a longer lifespan, often lasting 50+ years. Shingles, usually made of asphalt, are more affordable upfront but have a shorter lifespan of 15–25 years and may require more frequent maintenance or replacement.

• Is a Metal Roof Heavier Than Shingles for Home Construction?

No, metal roofs are often lighter than asphalt shingles. Metal roofing panels are designed to be both strong and lightweight, putting less strain on a home’s structural framework. This makes metal roofing a viable option for many types of buildings, including homes that might not support the weight of heavy roofing materials.

• Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost: Is a Metal Roof Cheaper Than Shingles?

In terms of initial installation costs, metal roofs are generally more expensive than shingles, with metal starting at around $4.49 per square foot and premium options reaching $9-$18 per square foot. Shingles, on the other hand, typically range from $2.50 to $5 per square foot. However, due to its longer lifespan and lower maintenance needs, a metal roof can be more cost-effective over time. In the Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost debate, metal roofing can offer significant savings in energy efficiency, maintenance, and longevity despite a higher upfront investment.

• Is Steel Roofing Better Than Shingles?

Steel roofing is often considered better than shingles for its durability, resistance to weather elements, and energy efficiency. Steel roofs are highly durable, can withstand high winds, and reflect sunlight, which can reduce cooling costs. However, shingles may still be a good choice for homeowners prioritizing a lower initial cost or those living in milder climates. For homeowners planning to stay in their home long-term, the Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost often leans in favor of metal roofing due to fewer replacements.

• Is a Metal Roof Noisier Than Asphalt Shingles?

Metal roofs can be noisier than asphalt shingles during heavy rain or hail, as metal naturally amplifies sound more than asphalt. However, insulation layers and solid underlayment can significantly reduce noise, making the difference in sound negligible for many homeowners.

• Which Type Is Easier to Install?

Shingles are typically easier to install than metal roofing, especially for roofing professionals with shingle experience. Metal roofing, particularly standing seam, requires specialized skills and tools. As a result, shingle installations are often quicker and more straightforward, leading to lower labor costs.

• What Is the Biggest Problem with Metal Roofs and With Shingles?

The biggest problem with metal roofs is their potential for dents and cosmetic damage from hail or falling debris, although high-quality metals are designed to resist these impacts. For shingles, the primary concern is wear and tear from animals and weather, such as wind lifting and water damage, which can lead to more frequent repairs or replacement needs.

Read more: Top 10 Metal Roofing Companies in Ontario

Final thoughts about metal roof vs shingles cost

In the end, metal vs shingles cost ultimately comes down to what you value most as a homeowner. Metal roofs might be a smart choice if you want a roof that will last through decades of harsh weather, save you money on your energy bills, and need little to no maintenance. Though more expensive to install in the beginning, metal roofs are durable and cost-effective when it comes to reducing energy costs. A metal roof means you’re making an investment in quality and security, particularly if you plan on being in your home for years to come. 

When considering Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost, think about your long-term plans; metal roofing may cost more initially but could save thousands over its lifetime.

Shingles might be a better choice for those looking for a cheaper upfront investment or those interested in a shorter-term ownership. Asphalt shingles are an easy, cost-effective, and multi-functional choice, and they’re also easier to put up, saving on labour. However, shingles have shorter life cycles and higher maintenance requirements, and so might eventually cost more in the long run.

Either way, you’ll want to check with a roofing contractor to find out exactly what your home requires and receive a precise estimate. The right roof can boost the value, comfort and protection of your home, giving you long-term financial and practical benefits.