Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles: Durability, Cost & Curb Appeal Compared

When it comes time to build or replace your roof, one of the first decisions to make is what material to use. After all, this is one of your property’s most important and expensive parts. You want a material that will withstand the weather, help your home run efficiently, and even enhance its appearance and value. In Canada (or, specifically, Alberta and Ontario), your roof must also resist heavy snowfall and freeze-thaw cycles, hailstorms, and stronger winds than in other parts of North America. There is a lot to consider, so we at Professional Metal Roofing have put together this comparison to help you weigh the pros and cons of metal roofing and asphalt shingles. We cover durability, both short and long-term costs, and curb appeal to give you the facts you need to make an informed decision.

Durability & Longevity: Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

• Lifespan

How long should your roof last? A properly installed metal roof can last 40 to 60+ years before it needs major replacement or repairs. An asphalt shingle roof has a more limited lifespan. Most last 15 to 25 years depending on the quality of shingles used and the local conditions.

• Resistance to Canadian Weather

Weather is the biggest test of all. Metal is fantastic in even Canada’s harshest climates. It can hold up under significant snowfall and high winds without cracking or blowing off. In snow-prone regions, the smooth metal panels shed snow before it can accumulate. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, have a rougher surface that tends to catch snow and adds to the risk of structural stress or ice dams.

• Freeze-Thaw Cycles

Water can enter any small gaps in roofing materials, then freeze and expand when temperatures drop. Asphalt shingles become brittle in extreme cold and are more likely to crack. Metal panels do not become brittle and stay structurally strong at any temperature.

• Hail and Impact Resistance

Hail can bruise or puncture asphalt shingles, leading to patching jobs or a need for premature replacement. Metal roofs are more hail-resistant. You might have to fix a large hailstorm’s dents on a metal roof, but the surface rarely gets compromised enough to let water in.

• Wind Resistance and Fire Performance

Metal is also far more wind-resistant. Gusts that could blow off shingles are less likely to damage a metal roof. Metal does not burn and is far more fire-resistant as well.

• Maintenance Requirements

Metal roofs require almost no maintenance. Asphalt shingle roofs demand more: regular inspections and maintenance, possible moss or algae treatment, and eventual replacement.

Upfront Costs vs. Long-Term Value

Metal roofs are more expensive than asphalt shingles. The materials and specialized installation often come at a premium. An average-sized asphalt roof is a cheaper option, at least in the short term. But the long-term value of a metal roof might save you money in the long run. Consider that you will likely have to replace an asphalt roof twice or even three times over the lifespan of a metal roof. Plus, the long-term maintenance and repair costs are lower for metal.

• Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs often have reflective coatings, which can help keep the attic cooler in summer months. They are also better at holding in warmth in winter months when paired with proper insulation. The energy efficiency of metal roofs is another way they save you money over time.

• Home Resale Value

Metal roofs are also seen as a premium addition. Many homebuyers look for metal roofs or even insist on them because of the known durability, protection, and modern appearance they provide. So, while you pay more to install a metal roof, it will likely give your property a boost in resale value.

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles: Curb Appeal Compared

1. Asphalt Shingles – More Traditional Appearance

Pros: Asphalt shingles are available in many colors and styles. From flat three-tab shingles to architectural styles that add texture and dimension, they can work with many other roof elements.

Cons: Asphalt shingles are very common, which makes them look less unique. An asphalt roof may not have the same “wow” factor as a metal roof.

2. Metal Roofing – Offers Modern, Contemporary Appearance

Pros: Metal roofing comes in a wide variety of profiles and finishes. You can choose from simple, sleek standing seam panels to metal tiles that closely resemble wood shakes or slate. Metal roofs also come in a wide range of vibrant or neutral colors, as well as special finishes that resist fading.

Cons: You can’t mistake a metal roof for asphalt. They can have a more modern appearance that may not work with all neighborhoods.

3. Matching Your Roof with the Neighbourhood

If you live in a traditional neighborhood, you are probably best off with asphalt shingles. A metal roof can look out of place. But metal roofing has also evolved to the point where it can be customized to more closely resemble classic materials. In this way, it can better blend with traditional styles if desired.

4. Appearance Over the Long Term

Asphalt shingles will fade over time and may develop unsightly algae streaks. Metal roofing is more resistant to both, requiring little upkeep to maintain its appearance.

Metal Roofing: The Long-Term Benefits

• Low Maintenance and Fewer Repairs

Metal roofs are resistant to rot, mold, mildew, and other types of frequent storm damage. Your metal roof will probably require nothing more than occasional inspections and roof cleaning.

• Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs with their reflective coatings reduce summer heat gain. Plus, metal roofing works with your insulation to provide better indoor temperature control and lower utility bills year-round.

• Home Resale Value

Potential buyers see a metal roof and associate it with quality. It also gives them the peace of mind of not needing to replace the roof soon. That may help you sell your home at a higher price.

• Environmentally Friendly

Metal panels are often made from recycled materials, and they are 100 percent recyclable at the end of their useful life. Asphalt shingles are typically destined for a landfill.

Why Professional Metal Roofing

• Years of Experience and Expertise

Our professional installers have extensive experience installing metal roofs across Alberta and Ontario. From residential homes to commercial buildings, we understand the unique requirements of each project. Visit our Our Works page to see examples of our completed roofing installations and the long-lasting results we deliver.

• High-Quality Metal Roofing Materials

We use only top-quality metal roofing in a variety of colors and styles. We carry durable, high-quality metal roofing materials that have strong warranties to back them up.

• Knowledge of Local Climate

We also understand the challenges of both Canadian winters and summers. We use this knowledge to ensure your roof will be energy efficient and weather-resistant for years.

• Superior Customer Service

Customer service is also a key difference. We are here for you at every stage: consultation, installation, and even after the job is done to provide long-term support.

Ready for Your New Roof: Metal or Asphalt?

Both metal roofing and asphalt shingles have their place in Canadian construction. Asphalt roofing may make more sense for your short-term budget. Metal roofing can save you money in the long run and is often the more durable, efficient, and beautiful choice. In Canada, and especially in Alberta and Ontario, metal is often the smart choice.

Still not sure? Not a problem. Contact Professional Metal Roofing and we’ll help you find a solution that works for your home or building. We’ll be happy to advise and provide a free, no-obligation quote. Get started on a new roof that can give you beauty, protection, and peace of mind for decades to come.