Hidden Fasteners or Exposed? Find the Best Option for Your Metal Roof

There are two main types of metal roofing systems: those with hidden fasteners, like standing seam roofs, and those with exposed fasteners, like metal tile roofs.
Each style offers specific benefits depending on your priorities—durability, maintenance, budget, and aesthetic.
Both systems perform exceptionally well in Canada’s climate, from snowy winters to scorching summers, and are widely used in residential projects by Professional Metal Roofing.

What Is a Standing Seam Metal Roof?

Standing seam metal roofing uses long, interlocking steel panels with raised seams that conceal fasteners underneath.
This creates a sleek, modern profile with no visible screws—an ideal solution for homeowners seeking durability and minimal upkeep.

Key Benefits:

• Concealed fasteners for superior weather resistance and durability.
• Sleek, continuous appearance with vertical interlocking panels.
• Excellent performance in heavy snow, rain, and wind.
• Low-maintenance and long-lasting roofing option.

What Is a Metal Tile Roof?

Metal tile roofs, or metal shingle roofs, use panels shaped to resemble traditional materials like clay, slate, or wood.
They’re installed with exposed screws on the surface, sealed with rubber washers for waterproofing.

Key Benefits:

• Traditional aesthetic with profiles mimicking tile, shake, or slate.
• Available in various colors, finishes, and stone-coated designs.
• Designed to handle hail, snow, and high winds.
• Easier to install and repair compared to standing seam roofs.

Durability and Weather Resistance

Both roofing styles offer excellent durability, but standing seam roofs generally have the edge due to their seamless design.

Standing Seam:

• No exposed screws means fewer leak points.
• Raised seams shed snow and water efficiently.
• Excellent for wet, snowy, and windy conditions.
• Typically remains leak-free for decades with minimal upkeep.

Metal Tile:

• Corrugated or tile shape adds rigidity and impact resistance.
• Exposed screws may loosen, or rubber washers may degrade over time.
• Requires periodic inspection and maintenance.
• Still highly durable when installed correctly.

Installation and Maintenance

Standing Seam:

• Requires skilled professional installation.
• Special tools and precise alignment are needed.
• Not suitable for DIY projects.
• Virtually maintenance-free after installation.

Metal Tile:

• Easier to install, even for experienced DIYers.
• The installation process is similar to asphalt shingles.
• Exposed screws need to be checked and tightened over time.
• Damaged panels can be replaced individually.

To see real-life examples of both standing seam and metal tile roof installations, visit the Our Works page.

Cost Comparison

Standing Seam:

• Higher initial cost due to custom panels and professional labor.
• Long lifespan and minimal maintenance reduce lifetime cost.
• Around 15–25% more expensive upfront than metal tile.

Metal Tile:

• Lower initial cost thanks to simpler installation.
• Some ongoing maintenance is required.
• Total ownership cost can be comparable in the long term.

Energy Efficiency and Environmental Impact

Both roofing systems are more energy-efficient than traditional shingles and environmentally friendly, but standing seam has a few extra advantages.
According to Natural Resources Canada, reflective metal roofs can help reduce cooling costs and improve home energy performance.

Standing Seam:

• Reflects sunlight effectively to reduce cooling costs.

• No surface penetrations help maintain insulation.

• Solar panels easily attach without drilling holes.

Metal Tile:

• Also reflects heat well, but may retain slightly more warmth.

• Requires custom mounts for solar panels.

• Made from recyclable steel, just like standing seam.

Aesthetic Considerations and Curb Appeal

Choosing a roof style also comes down to personal taste and home design.

Standing Seam:

• Sleek, modern appearance with bold, clean lines.
• Great for contemporary, minimalist, or industrial-style homes.
• Consistent panel color and smooth finish.
  

Metal Tile:

• Classic look mimicking tile, slate, or shake roofing.
• More dimension and texture in the profile.
• Suitable for heritage or traditional-style homes.
• Available in multi-tone and stone-coated finishes.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Standing Seam if you:

• Want a modern look with sleek lines.
• Prioritize maximum durability with little maintenance.
• Live in an area with harsh weather (snow, wind, rain).
• Plan to install solar panels on your roof.

Choose Metal Tile if you:

• Prefer a classic or traditional look.
• Have a tighter budget for your roofing project.
• Want easier repairs and more aesthetic options.

Ready to Choose Your Roof? Get a Free Estimate Today

At Professional Metal Roofing, we help Canadian homeowners make the best choice for their home and budget.
Whether you’re leaning toward the modern durability of standing seam or the classic charm of metal tile, our experienced team is here to help.

👉 Request a free estimate and get started on your project today!